Uneducated thoughts on Haiti
There are a lot smarter people out there with theology degrees that have spent years in school that probably know a lot more about any Biblical references I will make, so understand that these are just my thoughts based on how I view the world, and my own relationship with God.
This year, I’m reading through the One Year Chronological Bible. I’ve had it for a few years, and finally made the commitment to get to it this year. So far, so good.
Right now, I’m in Job. Full disclosure, I’ve never read all of Job before. I’ve read a few chapters here and there before, and I know the premiss of the story, but I’ve never read through it. I’m glad I am right now though, it’s super legit, you should check it out sometime.
Well anyway, last night I’m cruising easy through chapters 32-34, and I’m really getting into it. I kind of like this Elihu guy. I was talking to my friend Jonathon Wright about it earlier today, and he said that he sees the guy as kind of a punk kid who wants to give his two cents. He makes it a point to say, basically, “I’m young, but that doesn’t mean I can’t have some wisdom right? So now you guys have all had your say, so let me have mine!” I imagine Job, Bildad, Eliphaz, and Zophar just letting the kid say what he feels like he has to say and not really considering him of any consequence.
So here’s Elihu chugging along in his discourse about how if Job really is so righteous and sinless, then how come God is jackin’ with all of his bidness?! Hmmm Job…hmmmmm? And he says this in 34:12:
It is unthinkable that God would do wrong,
That the Almighty would pervert justice.
So here’s this young guy saying, “If you’re really so good Job, then why is God doing all of this to you? He cannot do wrong. Because of who He is, and His very nature, He can’t do anything bad!” Now, he is 100% correct there. But in the context of the situation, he (and Job and his friends) didn’t understand that it wasn’t God doing any of this, but He was allowing it to happen to prove a point to Satan.
So, the first thing that came to my mind when I read that verse though, was Haiti. The second was Katrina hitting New Orleans in 2005. After both events, we have people (finite creatures created by an Infinite God) claiming that God did it to pass judgement on the sins of both places (And it’s not just “famous”…or maybe infamous…people like Pat Robertson, it’s our friends and neighbors as well). In 2005, Tony Campolo made the point that if that WAS the case, then how come the French Quarter (widely considered to be the center of debauchery in New Orleans) was left virtually untouched. It was a great point. To my knowledge, there have been no such defenses like that made for Haiti…so maybe Robertson was right.
Kidding. I’m kidding. Give me a few more minutes, and I’ll make my real point.
In the Old Testament, when we see judgement passed by God on a nation, or people, or person, or whatever the case may be, it was to give them an opportunity to turn back to him. I’m not going to list all of the instances here, but go look into it, if I’m wrong come back and let me know. I will concede.
So here’s the thing. Or…my opinion of “the thing”. What happened in New Orleans in 2005, and in Haiti a few days ago (and the tsunami a few years back, and other catastrophic natural disasters) was tragic. It’s not our place though to decide whether or not they are judgement by God upon those people . I look at it this way. The sins of the poverty stricken people of Haiti, are no worse than my middle class sins here in America. If the earthquake there really was judgement for a “pact made with the Devil” (I’d seriously like to see some historically documented proof of that), why not instead afflict the descendants of the people who made the pact, instead of causing catastrophic damage to one of the most poverty stricken countries in the world? The God of Love who I know, is not in the business of settling petty centuries old “wrongs” done to Him.
Now, that being said, I’m not the Omnipotent Creator Of All. If I was, we’d all be in a lot of trouble. Because, by nature I am in the business of settling the score for petty wrongs done to me. I think we have a perverted sense of the way God does justice. Like I said before, in the O.T., He used it as a means to bring people (usually His people, Israel) back to Him. Was it usually the last resort for Him? I think so. I think He gave chance after chance, and finally had to bring them almost to their end, and then allow them to embrace Him again. I don’t think God made the earthquake in Haiti happen (though He could have)…I think it is more likely that He would take a hand of protection off of them and allow something like that to happen.
So. I don’t think it’s my place, or your place, or the place of Pat Robertson, or anyone else to say, “Yep, just got a phone call from The Almighty, He said to make sure everyone knows that He totally wasted that place because He was super pissed at them”. It is our place to love that country, and those people through their situation regardless of how we feel about what happened. We gave up any other choice when we accepted the gift of grace on the cross. And it is our place to know that it is unthinkable that God would do wrong, or that the Almighty would pervert justice. Everything that happens, He does ordain, but it is all for the glory of His name. Doesn’t matter whether or not we see that.
-David
Interesting observations, Sir. I think you hit on sometime crutial in the last paragraph: no human is God and is authorized to speak for him (the One who could was killed for it!
In a broad sense, I believe all natural disaster are broad judgements of sorts because creation is fallen (wouldn’t happen without the presence of sin, right?) I also did read a historical reference where a Haitian man sacrificed a pig and made a pact with the devil (and sometimes, as the scripture (OT) says, the sins of the fathers can be visited on the sons (daughters?) to… I think it says 3rd & 4th generation… surely you have experienced this in your family or seen it in a friend’s family.)
BUT I do not believe this is what is happening in Haiti. I believe the laws of nature that God has put in place are playing out. Did he cause the earthquake? It’s fine language in whether he caused it or allowed it, but in either case he was fully aware it was happening and when and how. He was not sleeping nor was he surprised. If God is sovereign, as he has said he is, he has a plan to work out even in this!
Far more important than any other thing, Jesus modeled love. This can blanket everyone in this situation, even silly ol’ wrong-speaking Pat and anyone who would lash out at his misspoken words. Any other response sidetracks our efforts and causes us to forget the main goal. Forgiveness is born out of love. Relief is born out of compassion. Restoration can always happen out of disaster (as you have said.)
I don’t believe Jesus came the previous time to spread judgement. When he spoke, he spoke of judgement to come, but not nearly as much as he spoke of (and demonstrated) love, redemption and healing. This is the time of redemption, healing and love before he ultimately returns in judgement, but even that will contain redemption, restoration and renewal!
BTW, there’s a really good link on my FB to Relevant Mag response to Pat R by Donald Miller. Give it a read… it’s great! Keep thinking, reading, meditating and my friend. Those will give you everything you need! ;]
One other thing: you touched on the finite and the infinite. The finite cannot mentally or spiritually hold in tension the thoughts the infinite can… they seem to contradict to the finite. To God, they can go hand in hand, no problemo (we end up dividing denominations etc. over it!) That was what was happening to Elihu, I believe, and Job, others… maybe that thought will help you will Job, or maybe you knew it.
Hey cuz! I was just stalkin’ your blog (like I do) and I wanted to say that I really liked this post. A lot. Like, I want to email it to Pat Robertson.
Anyway, keep being awesome. I love you!
-Brooke
PS. Interesting fact: Job is my favorite book of the Old Testament. It’s so beautifully written that I could read it over and over again in whatever language and just never get tired of it.